Theatre Review Roundup / Published 2026-10-30

“A Few Good Men” Revival Opens on Broadway With Bradley Whitford and Tom Blyth

Lincoln Center Theater's revival of Sorkin's A Few Good Men opened Thursday with Bradley Whitford and Tom Blyth. Deadline calls the staging handsome; TheWrap calls the play creaky.

A conceptual illustration of a bare theatre stage set with a plain wooden bench and two empty chairs on a light wooden floor.
Conceptual editorial illustration; not a production photograph or a film still.

THE SHORT VERSION

  • A Few Good Men opened on Thursday at Broadway's Vivian Beaumont Theater in a Lincoln Center Theater revival directed by Michael Arden, with Bradley Whitford as Col. Nathan Jessep and Tom Blyth as Lt. Daniel Kaffee.
  • Deadline's Greg Evans calls the staging handsome and Whitford a worthy villain, but says the play's power to shock feels drained; TheWrap calls the revival a creaky old play and Blyth's cross-examination weak.
  • Both reviews credit Dane Laffrey's large set and measure the production against the 1992 film; neither reports a closing date or box-office figures.

The revival opened Thursday at the Vivian Beaumont

Lincoln Center Theater’s revival of A Few Good Men opened on Thursday at the Vivian Beaumont Theater, the Broadway house inside Lincoln Center where the company stages its work. TheWrap records the venue and the night, and notes that the theater’s current management has been pairing familiar screen titles with stage revivals, starting with Ragtime last season and continuing with The Sound of Music later. Deadline credits Aaron Sorkin as the writer and Michael Arden as director, and lists a running time of 2 hr 35 min including an intermission.

Deadline prints the full cast: Tom Blyth, Bradley Whitford, Krysta Rodriguez, Stephanie Berry, Nick Blaemire, Michael Braugher, Christopher Gurr, Billy Eugene Jones, Collin Kelly-Sordelet, Shunté Lofton, Michael Oberholtzer, Lavel Schley, Thom Sesma, Daniel Velez and John Zdrojeski. TheWrap assigns the principals: Whitford as Lt. Col. Nathan R. Jessep, Blyth as Lt. j.g. Daniel Kaffee, Rodriguez as Lt. Cmdr. JoAnne Galloway and Daniel Velez as PFC William T. Santiago, the Marine whose death sets the case in motion.

“You can’t handle the truth” as a test of the staging

Both reviews treat the play’s best-known line as a test of the production. Deadline says that when “You can’t handle the truth!” arrives it feels “both very, very familiar and ever so slightly tossed off, maybe even rushed, as if this Broadway revival of Aaron Sorkin’s A Few Good Men doesn’t want cheap applause or an audience even momentarily distracted by cinematic nostalgia.” It notes that the line is printed on T-shirts sold at the Lincoln Center merchandise table.

Deadline adds that Blyth’s Kaffee demands the truth in a more conversational tone than Tom Cruise’s “sputtering delivery” in the 1992 film, and that Whitford’s punchline is “as forceful as it needs to be.” Its summary of the exchange is qualified: “All in all, the famous exchange is less histrionic than we might remember,” followed by “Anti-climactic? A bit maybe.” TheWrap does not analyse the line; it argues instead that Blyth’s cross-examination of Whitford is weaker than Cruise’s confrontation with Jack Nicholson.

Deadline: handsome staging, drained shock

Greg Evans, writing for Deadline, calls Arden’s staging “handsome” and says the revival “almost feels vital,” because its subject — a commander who shifts blame for a negligent death onto two Marines who followed orders — reads as more relevant now than in 1989. He also argues that the play’s “power to shock feels drained,” since the bullying commander at its centre says nothing audiences do not already hear on the news, which leaves the courtroom drama “without much drama.”

The review faults the production for declining to revise the text. It holds up Sorkin’s adaptation of To Kill a Mockingbird, which it calls “remarkable,” and argues that revivals work best when they force an audience to rethink long-held assumptions. It suggests the play would be more compelling if Sorkin had given Galloway enough material to be more than “a Jiminy Cricket” pushing Kaffee toward heroism, and says the revival offers no new angle on its villain.

TheWrap: a creaky old play with an easy solution

TheWrap reaches a blunter conclusion. It recalls that the 1989 Broadway production took a single Tony nomination, for lead actor Tom Hulce, and lost the Best Play race to Lettice & Lovage, then says the revival “makes it clear that the Tony Awards got it right.” Its judgment follows in five words: A Few Good Men is “a creaky old play.”

The central complaint is that the case resolves too easily. TheWrap writes that the two defence lawyers “don’t make their case; it is handed to them when a subordinate (Thom Sesma) snitches on Jessep, then conveniently commits suicide,” and that Jessep’s collapse on the witness stand is “equally easy-peasy.” It also says the play “begins much like a rom-com,” with a contrived fight between two lawyers who could not be more different.

Whitford divides praise from Blyth

The reviews agree on Whitford. Deadline says he “subverts” the amiability audiences know from The West Wing’s Josh Lyman, turning “zealous and mean,” and calls his Jessep “a worthy villain” and “a depressingly recognizable monster.” TheWrap describes the same character as “a God-fearing fascist,” and treats his confrontation with Kaffee as the evening’s real contest.

They diverge on Blyth. Deadline says the actor “puts his boyishness to good use” and makes Kaffee’s turn from “frat-boy arrogance to righteous justice-seeker” a credible payoff, calling the result “Atticus Finch-in-dress-whites.” TheWrap calls his takedown of Whitford “weak.” On Rodriguez, Deadline says her Galloway is “committed” but may seem “ancillary” because the writing gives her little to carry; TheWrap calls her “the epitome of earnest dedication to the rule of law.”

The set, the director’s background and what neither review reports

Both reviews single out Dane Laffrey’s set. Deadline describes an airy design that uses the large Lincoln Center stage to make the courtroom “merely one portion of the metaphoric stakes,” with a lonely army cot that doubles as an autopsy table, a locker-room area and an observation tower looming overhead. TheWrap agrees the set is mammoth but says it “only highlights the play’s weaknesses,” and argues that the production “unspools on the vast Vivian Beaumont stage as if it were really a screenplay.”

TheWrap notes that Arden usually directs musicals, credits him with Tony Awards for Parade and Maybe Happy Ending, and says that here he has “substituted singing with lots of yelling from his actors.” Neither review reports a closing date for the run, ticket sales or a casting change, and neither describes an announcement beyond the opening itself. Related coverage on this site includes the theatrical release of Social Reckoning, the New York run of Only Living Pickpocket and the BFI London Film Festival 2026 winners.

Sources & reporting limits

  1. ‘A Few Good Men’ Broadway Review: Bradley Whitford And Tom Blyth Manhandle The Truth — Deadline
  2. ‘A Few Good Men’ Broadway Review: Aaron Sorkin Drama Is Guilty of Being a Creaky Old Play — TheWrap
Keep the thread.

Follow Film to find related stories on your next visit.

THE WEEKLY EDIT

The week, made clear.

Stories worth understanding, brought together in one weekly edition.

Share this page

Instagram, TikTok & other apps

Copy the page link, then paste it where your chosen app supports links. You choose whether to send or publish.